I’ve been through the mill with a few of these and it’s a growing list of options. I should start by saying that I love GitHub and use it regularly for a large number of projects (including some of my own, some for my company and some for my customers). The only problem I have with GitHub is that I just haven’t made the jump to trust it with our proprietaryÂ code – the primary asset of the company. Particularly after a high profile security breech.
Now, nothing I’ve come across yet comes close to GitHub. But two we use daily have good matching features:
- Gitorious – Â whether they intended it or not, it’s a good clone of GitHub but always a little behind on features. It’s also a Ruby on Rails application and the documentation is getting far better. When we started, it was pretty… shite, to be honest. Installing and upgrading was a pain. They have addressed this withÂ http://getgitorious.com/Â which includes a virtual appliance for VirtualBox so you can be up and running in minutes.
- Atlassian Stash – if you’re a small team (<= 10 users) then this could be for you. Installation is pretty easy, it looks great, is very fast (over HTTP/S, but it’s inbuilt SSH client is extremely slow) and is very easy to use. Pull requests are also done really really well. It’s a full Java webapp so it does require some CPU and memory. For <= 10 users, my definiteÂ favorite. Thereafter though it gets expensive – e.g. for up to 25 users you’ll fork out $1,800 / annum. That’s not entirely unaffordable but if you’re using Stash, then you may also be using their other products such as Jira, Confluence, Bamboo, Fisheye and Crucible. Now that adds up to a hefty bill!
One’s I have not tested and so cannot speak authoritively on include:
- GitLab – Looks like a very interesting alternative.
- RhodeCode – they say it willÂ “change the way you manage your code”.
- Gitolite – a quick look at the available information for thisÂ definitelyÂ puts it in the also ran category. There’s no polish or anythingÂ nice to entice one to even try it.
- Gitosis – in their own words:Â “Manage git repositories, provide access to them over SSH, with tight access control and not needing shell accounts”. The project appears dead.